Apple, Lenovo lead losers in laptop repairability analysis

Apple and Lenovo had the lowest laptop repairability scores in an analysis of recently released devices from consumer advocacy group US Public Interest Research Group (PIRG) Education Fund. While Apple's low marks are partially due the difficulty involved in disassembling MacBooks, Lenovo appears to be withholding information from shoppers deemed critical to right-to-repair legislation and accessibility.

The report, US PIRG's fourth annual “Failing the Fix” [

Apple and Lenovo Fall Short

Apple's MacBooks scored poorly due to the inherent difficulty of disassembly. However, Lenovo's low scores raise eyebrows, as the company is suspected of withholding critical information that could assist in repair efforts.

Methodology and Scoring

US PIRG's report evaluated both PCs and smartphones from various brands. The repairability scores were calculated based on French Repairability Index scores and disassembly scores, with disassembly weighted more heavily.

Additionally, manufacturers were penalized for membership in industry groups that oppose right-to-repair legislation and rewarded for supporting such initiatives.

Consumer Implications

The findings of the report have significant implications for consumers. Poor repairability scores make it difficult and expensive to repair devices, leading to increased waste and financial burden.

Call for Transparency and Right-to-Repair

The report underscores the need for increased transparency from manufacturers regarding repair information. It also highlights the importance of legislation that empowers consumers with the right to repair their own devices.

Related Resources

• Failing the Fix Report
• US PIRG's Report
• TechNet Lobbying
• Consumer Technology Association Lobbying